
Extreme Makeover Home Edition
There was a good article in the Wall Street Journal this past Tuesday talking about some of the guests / homeowners who have been the subject of past Extreme Home Makeover episodes. The show undoubtedly does a lot of good for it’s homeowners but in some cases they have almost done too much for each family. The large homes built by the show’s producers for their shows featured families have in many cases been too large and too expensive for the family to maintain. As a result many have been weighed down financially by the upkeep cost and care for their McMansion homes.
We thought the article was interesting because the shows producers really were mirroring what was going on in the housing market all around us. Folks who were purchasing a home were buying more house than they could afford and those who were Remodeling an existing home were adding in over-the-top amenities that certainly look to be unnecessary today.
The article states that “back in the boom, the makeovers got a little out of hand because of competition among home builders aware of the free publicity that came with the show and who tried to outdo previous projects. These days, the show is backing away from the boom-era showpieces”.
Where it was common only a few years ago for the show to build their families 5,000 sf plus homes, today the average size of current makeovers is 2,800 to 3,000 sf.
Examples of past homes show projects that were built for families with modest incomes yet were 5,000 sf or more and different projects included among other things a movie theater, a carousel, and an English castle in one case.
While the show’s executives had good intentions, the properties in many cases were not in line with the budgets of the families that had moved in and occupied the properties once the show had moved on. When the large heating and electricity bills came followed by large property tax payments, and the inevitable on-going maintenance costs (who to call when the carousel breaks) the burdens for many just became too much to bear.
Many owners have sought loan modifications to reduce their payments to stay in their home. Others have been forced to sell. But in either case, the experience of homeowners from the show really parallels that happening in communities all across the country with struggling homeowners who took on more than their budgets would allow. We thought the article was quite interesting for these parallels to what we are reading about and hearing on our news programs everyday.